Crazy Phazy Guitar Issues... why is it happening?

Can you give us a screen shot of your mixer with the guitars to look at? Rail

How are your stereo tracks recorded? If you're using a stereo delay you are probably having real phasing issues by doing what you are doing. I'm a little drunk right now, so I'll try to make sense... bear with me... When you record a stereo track using a stereo delay, one side will have a slight phase shift from the other side. Since you're taking one side from one track and adding another side from another track, you are probably inducing a phase shift big enough to cause some serious cancellations. Hope that made sense, Paul

I wish I could give you a screenshot but the PT rig is at my studio where I dont have a net connection. The tracks were recorded with 1 SM57 mic into a tube preamp with stereo outs and phase inverted on one signal.

I'm just a little curious as to why you are recording an amp in this fashion. Could you explain why you are taking this approach? Thanks, Paul

Its all about options. On one song we just ended up using the stereo image of 1 guitar and on others we used just 1 track from each guitar stereo pair...I am still trying to understand why the tracks phase when panned over 60-65L L-R. I think it may be a pro-tools issue, I have never run into that on an analog console with a studor.

Anyone?!?!?!

email me a screen shot so we can see what you're doing.. it's definately not an inherent bug in Pro Tools. Rail